PART IV - THE FIRST STAGECOACH
ROBBERY IN THE WEST
As soon as gold was discovered at Sutter’s Mill men from around the
world flooded into California. The treasure from remote regions was
taken out on pack trains. This seemed the perfect scenario for road
agents to operate, but there were no robberies until 1851 Charley Smith
stepped out of the brush and waylaid a pack train carrying gold dust.
More robberies soon followed by such bad men as Reelfoot Williams and
Dick Barter, alias Rattlesnake Dick, but these were robberies from pack
trains, not stagecoaches. In early 1850 Thomas J. Hodges, alias Tom
Bell, appeared on the scene. He had been a bar room brawler in his
earlier days, and in one affray had his nose crushed so badly that it
was nearly flat on his face, except for a small protrusion that had a
deep dent in the tip. This made his appearance decidedly repulsive, very
distinctive, and gave him the appearance of being much older than his
twenty years. After escaping prison, Bell formed and led a gang of
desperadoes made up of other escaped convicts and bad men.
On the morning of August 12, 1856 Sam Langston’s Express Company
stagecoach left Camptonville for Marysville with John Greer driving and
Bill Dobson riding guard. On board was a treasure box containing
$100,000 in gold dust. The stagecoach made its routine stop at the
California House twenty-five miles from Marysville, where Bell’s spy
disembarked and reported the treasure was aboard. The gang rode hard and
at 4:30 P.M. Bell, Bill Gristy and Ned Convery rode out of the brush and
pointed their guns at Greer and Dobson. Monte Jack, “English” Bob Carr,
and Juan Rocher were assigned to cover the stagecoach from the opposite
side of the road, but they were some distance away. With all the road
agents on one side of the coach Dobson did not hesitate and opened fire
with his rifle, and several armed passengers joined in the fracas with
their pistols. The stagecoach lurched forward at a run as Dobson, though
wounded in his arm, swung around to return fire as the road agents shot
at the fleeing coach. In all over forty shots were exchanged in less
than a minute. After traveling a safe distance Greer stopped and took
stock of their situation. Dobson was wounded in his arm; passenger John
Campbell had received a grazing shot to his forehead; another passenger
had been shot in both legs; but worst of all the Negress wife of the
town barber, Mrs. Tilghman, had been shot through the brain and killed
instantly.
The robbers had not thought to wear masks and from their description it
was clear that it was the Bell gang, led by Bell himself. Throughout
northern California citizens demanded that the Bell gang be rounded up
and hanged, or imprisoned. In September a member of the Bell gang was
captured and this led to the killing or arrest of several fugitives.
When Bill Gristy received word to join Bell, he started out for
Firebaugh’s Ferry, but when he got to Knight’s Ferry he decided to stop
for a meal. He was captured and Major T. W. Lane, who learned that Bell
was hiding on a farm six miles above Firebaugh’s Ferry. Lane’s posse
missed their quarry, watched for some time without results, and then
disbanded. Robert Price, a member of Lane’s posse, started for Sonora
and, upon crossing the river to take the road northeast, saw Bell hiding
in the brush. He summoned the posse and at 11:00 A.M. they got the drop
on Bell.
They took their prisoner to Firebaugh’s Ferry, where he confessed to
many crimes, so the men decided to hang their prisoner. It was nearly
5:00 P.M. before Bell finished his preparations. He blamed drink and
gambling for his end as he walked the fifty feet to the sturdy sycamore
tree. He took one last swig of whiskey when it was offered and then
began to pray in a low tone. The men simply marched away holding the
loose end of the rope and tied it to the tree trunk, and Bell slowly
strangled to death. Bell’s body was cut down and buried in an unmarked
grave nearby.
Part 5